editor@360hinduism.com
| |
yoga effect, yoga and pranayam

How Might Yoga Work? An Overview of Potential Underlying Mechanisms

yoga effect, yoga and pranayam

Marcy C. McCall

Sc. Kellogg College, University of Oxford, UK

Introduction

Popular and academic interest in yoga for treatment of health conditions are increasing at an alarming rate while over 30 million people claim to practice yoga for health benefit worldwide [1]. The practice of yoga originates from 5000 BCE in India to combine specific postures (asanas), breathing techniques (pranayama), meditative techniques (dhyana), chants (mantras) and wisdom teachings (sutras) to encourage union with body and mind [2]. Yoga therapy is the “process of empowering individuals to progress toward improved health and well-being through the application of the philosophy and practice of Yoga” [3]. Today, nearly 14 million Americans (6.1% of the population) say that a doctor or therapist has recommended yoga to them for their health condition [4]. In the United Kingdom, national healthcare services promote yoga as a safe and effective way to promote physical activity, improving strength, balance and flexibility as well as a potential benefit for people with high blood pressure, heart disease, aches and pains, depression and stress [5].

Over 2000 health and yoga-related journal articles are published online (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed). A recent summary (2012) indicates that there is relatively strong evidence to suggest that yoga may have beneficial effects for pain-associated disability and mental health [6]. A preceding overview (2010) shows unanimously positive evidence emerged for depression and cardiovascular risk reduction with yoga, with little supporting evidence to suggest benefit for patients with epilepsy, asthma or various pain conditions [7]. A further clinical review suggests that psychological symptoms and disorders (anxiety, depression, sleep), pain syndromes, autoimmune conditions (asthma, multiple sclerosis), immune conditions (lymphoma, breast cancer), pregnancy and weight loss can all be positively affected by yoga [8]. From an evidence-based healthcare perspective, the hypothetical underlying mechanisms to explain potential effects of yoga are in the early stages of investigation. In response to the Medical Research Council’s guidelines for evaluating complex interventions [9,10], a coherent theoretical basis should be established in advance of further research development.

Purpose of this Review

As evidence suggests, yoga has a potential role in the prevention and treatment of numerous health conditions. The theoretical basis for health effects is important to clinicians, researchers and yoga practitioners. The purpose of this literature review is to synthesize the current hypotheses and scientific evidence for underlying mechanisms of yoga intervention.

Methodology

Inclusion criteria

Type of articles: Any clinical investigation, review or evidence synthesis that explores potential underlying mechanisms for yoga’s effect in a health-related context is included. Authors must name yoga as the primary focus of their research. To improve the quality of data, only peer-reviewed articles published on-line within public medical research databases after January 1, 2006 are included. Hypotheses presented without sufficient scientific evidence are set aside and presented as emergent hypotheses.

Type of mechanisms: Any yoga mechanism or description that includes underlying effects of practicing yoga or explanations supported with scientific inquiry or preliminary evidence is included. Health outcomes such as blood pressure, reducing body weight or decreasing stress are insufficient for inclusion, though may be included if underlying mechanisms of these outcomes are discussed.

Type of yoga: Any type of yoga is included for review. A standardized definition of yoga in research is not available at this time. For the purposes of this review, a broad and conventional definition is a pragmatic choice, where the described yoga intervention must

include one or more of the following characteristics: (breathing techniques), asana (postures) and dhyana (meditation) and/or other yoga teachings.

Exclusion criteria

Articles that discuss interventions similar to yoga (i.e., massage, tai chi, talk therapy) are excluded. Research protocols or papers that discuss yoga mechanisms only in their introduction or study rationale are not included.

Search strategy

Databases: An on-line search of three scholarly databases includes the Cochrane Library, PubMed and Scopus databases. Conferences and websites of yoga institutions and references from found articles are also searched. Hand-searches in yoga-specific journals and books also performed to ensure a comprehensive search.

Online search terms and limitations: A rapid systematic search employs free-text terms: [yoga] AND [(mechanism OR pathway OR effect) AND (clinic* OR review)]. The literature search is current as of 1 December 2012.

Results

Description of included articles

The title-search identified 454 potential articles, 110 abstracts were screened and 24 full-text articles assessed for eligibility. Eighteen original articles are included in this literature review (Figure 1). A variety of outcome effects are presented in the literature, including treatment and prevention of cardiovascular disease (CVD), diabetes, obesity, arthritis, cancer, epilepsy and erectile dysfunction. Psychological wellbeing, relaxation, decrease in depression and anxiety, delayed aging, improved pain management and sleep quality were also discussed. Five of the articles introduce potential mechanisms that lack empirical evidence and will be discussed separately as emerging hypotheses. Table 1 lists the characteristics of included studies.

The characteristics of yoga intervention are not explicitly reported in the majority of cases, although asana practice appears most commonly cited (17 articles). The Oswal study [11] examines the effect of pranayama and dhyana components of yoga only. Six articles were excluded after initial screening because of insufficient empirical evidence to support theories, or yoga mechanisms are not the focus of the paper, or the paper includes interventions other than yoga (Table 2).

One of the 18 included reports identifies an adverse effect of yoga [12]. In this case, a female practitioner developed thrombosis of the vertebrobasilar artery due to an intimal tear and suffered a subsequent stroke. The nature of this injury is attributed to adopting an unusual neck posture [13].

Quality of included articles

One included article is a systematic review of underlying mechanisms for yoga [14] and receives a high-quality rating (AMSTAR=9) [15]. One randomized control trial [9] (n=30) reports double blinding and shows reasonable effort to minimize bias and appears to follow the CONSORT [16] guidelines for transparency and effective reporting procedures. Three controlled trials [17-19] are included, though the quality of evidence is low due to selective recruitment and lack of randomization with no mention of blinding techniques. Furthermore, in two instances the reporting of results does not match the authors’ hypotheses [18] and conclusions [17]. The remaining articles (13) are literature reviews or clinical reports and do not report on methodological considerations such as search protocols, inclusion or exclusion criteria of studies or rating the quality of evidence.

Overview of mechanisms

The empirical evidence supporting underlying mechanisms for clinical effects of yoga is limited. A current systematic overview or review that thoroughly assesses the quality and weight of evidence to support or reject hypotheses has not been found. Research interest for mechanisms that examine pathways originating in the endocrine system, nervous system and cardiovascular, respiratory and physical parameters of health (BMI, muscular strength, psychomotor skills, etc.) are most prevalent. Mechanisms that affect metabolism, circulation (BP, atherosclerosis) and behavioural or social tendencies are frequently cited. Figure 2 depicts a summary of evidence as expressed in empirical and hypothetical findings.

Empirical evidence

Endocrine system: The strongest evidence in both quality and quantity suggests yoga has a positive impact on hormone regulation. Salivary levels of cortisol have been measured and notably decreased in numerous reviews and trials [8,14,19,20]. Lowering cortisol is associated with decreasing perceived stress, decreasing anxiety, increasing feelings of well-being and improving pain management [21]. Enhanced serotonin production for erectile dysfunction [20], oxytocin released during visualization techniques to regulate bone mass [11] and higher levels of melatonin to improve immunity and sleep quality [12,22] are other potential effects of yoga practice.

Nervous system: An explanatory framework that attributes benefits of yoga through direct influence on the sympathetic and parasympathetic activity in the autonomic nervous system is common. Evidence suggests the respiratory effects of pranayama, visualization and calming techniques in dhyana as well as physical movement in asanas reduce sympathetic activation, increase levels of gamma- aminobutyric acid (GABA) [23], regulate the hypothalamic-pituitaryadrenal

(HPA) axis to improve outcomes in mood disorders [18], stress [24], well-being and provides an anxiolytic effect [22]. Physical health: Physical health includes cardiorespiratory fitness, kinesiology, and biomechanics including balance, flexibility and anthropometric characteristics. Yoga interventions to increase strength and balance have demonstrated a capacity to decrease falls and risk of injury in a geriatric population [25]. Exercise training effects in lowering resting heart rate, oxygen consumption rate, decrease in basal metabolic rate (BMR) and decreasing body mass index (BMI) and fat mass indicate preventative effects for cardiovascular disease, diabetes and obesity [8,12,14,17].

Metabolism: The metabolic effects of yoga have been most intensely studied for glycemic control. Evidence for improved glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity suggests that regular asana practice may replace drug therapies in type 2 diabetics [14]. Measureable improvements of clinical significance after yoga intervention are noted in fasting plasma glucose (FPG) and postprandial plasma glucose (PPPG) [17,26,27]. Balaji et al. [21] note increased hepatic lipase and lipoprotein lipase at the cellular level affects the metabolism and subsequent increase in uptake of triglycerides by adipose tissues. Circulatory system: The circulatory pathways of health-related outcomes include lowering blood pressure and improving arterial function. Three authors discuss the potential circulatory benefits that include: lowering blood pressure, enhancing cardiovagal function and slowing atherosclerosis to prevent cardiovascular disease [14] increasing blood flow with the prompting of visual techniques [11] and restoring baroreceptor sensitivity [10]. Behavioural/social: A decrease in food consumption, eating speed and positive food choices following a yoga treatment program is shown to be effective for binge eating [28]. Enhancing sleep quality to improve psychological well-being is noted in two studies [14,19]. Reducing social isolation, fostering networks that reinforce physical activity and self-care could lead to improved pain management [24] and healthier physical and psychological responses to stress [21].

Antioxidant: Oxidative stress results from an imbalance in the prooxdiant- antioxidant equilibrium and is associated with a number of diseases [29]. Numerous findings identify an increase in levels of total antioxidant status (TAS) and other naturally occurring antioxidants in human cells such as glutathione (GSH) and plasma vitamin E following yoga intervention [14,17,30]. Preventative and treatment effects for cardiovascular disease, cancer, arthritis, diabetes and Alzheimer’s have also been indicated in these research findings. One 3-month clinical trial with diabetic yoga practitioners achieved a 20% reduction in oxidative stress following long-term regular sessions [17].

Inflammation: Yoga’s effect on decreasing inflammatory markers is a recent addition to research. With a focus on pain management and effective treatment of depression, the partial role of reducing proinflammatory cytokines such as IL-6, interleukin-2, C-reactive protein is attributed to yoga’s capacity to stimulate the vagus nerve [18,21,26]. The vagus nerve in turn decreases heart rate, blood pressure or both to improve responses to stress and which may have further effects on decreasing obesity and improving immunity [31].

Psychology and cognition: In two articles, increased feelings of satisfaction, self-confidence and self-control are linked to decreased perceived stress and increased well-being following yoga practice [14,20]. Another author states that “if yoga therapy offers an awareness of physical and mental states, benefits for pain management for back pain and cancer-related therapies including breast cancer may result [21]”, though the empirical evidence is insufficiently robust to confirm predictions.

 Emerging Hypotheses

The following group of mechanisms belong to hypothetical areas of effect that depend on limited or indirect research for evidence.

Immunity

Two papers identify immunology for cancer treatment and stress reduction as a possible mediating factor and benefit of yoga practice [8,32]. Field [8] suggest yoga stimulates the vagal nerve that in turn reduces cortisol, the detriment of natural killers (NK) cells in the human body. This hypothesis was tested in women with breast cancer [33]. Results indicate that both lymphocytes and NK cells were increased following treatment and authors suggest the same effect may be triggered by yoga practice. Kulkarni et al. [32] propose further investigation of the molecular action on cellular, neuro-humoral and immune systems to reverse stress following yoga intervention.

Nerve conduction

For pain reduction, improved nerve conduction through ‘Gate theory stimulation’ and enhanced deep sleep to decrease ‘substance P’ as indicated through massage therapy may also demonstrate key benefits of yoga therapy [8], though empirical evidence is speculative.

Bioelectromagnetism

Various health effects and biological interactions are being explored through analysis of electrical and magnetic currents within our internal,

cellular structures and external, environmental surroundings (i.e., low-frequency magnetic fields) [34]. As an effective agent to optimize health, delay age and treat various chronic illnesses, yoga’s pranayamic breathing and meditation may positively influence the transduction pathways, including bioelectromagnetism [35]. Empirical evidence to support this theory is not currently available.

Discussion

There are several published theories and hypotheses for yoga’s effect on health outcomes in healthcare databases. Some of these theories seek to inform biomedical perspectives including neurological and biochemical underpinnings, while some theories compare yoga to massage, or explore alternative concepts such as bio-electromagnetism. Consensus on the biological plausibility or causal pathways of how yoga might work is not indicated in this review. The evidence to support current hypotheses is relatively weak; though 2000 yoga articles are published online, only 18 appear to be relevant to this research question and inclusion criteria. As a complementary therapy, yoga is becoming popular in both research and the wider community and it is important to address the fundamental questions regarding yoga’s impact on health outcomes. That is, not only does it work but if it does, how does it work?

Yoga as a complex intervention includes components with varying degrees of physical movement, mind-body exercises and in-depth philosophical teachings. Even though yoga literature emphasizes the psychological aspects of practice, current evidence focuses on conventional underlying effects of disease including hormone regulation and metabolism. Perhaps empirical study from new or integrated perspectives could include changes in behaviour or philosophical beliefs to increase the understanding and breadth of yoga as a health intervention. Some preliminary analysis of multiple yoga effects are offered in review papers [12,14], and will be helpful in evolving the discussion for causal pathways in disease-specific outcomes. A component-outcome analysis may also assist in improving evidence and dialogue.

Limitations of this review

The content of this review is largely limited by the quality and availability of publications in online health databases from three countries, the Netherlands (Scopus), United Kingdom (Cochrane Collaboration) and United States (PubMed). An in-depth search that includes other sources of information may yield different results. This search is current as of December 2012 and due to the pace of new research in this field, may be out of date by the time of publication. Still, the framework and rapid search offers an important structure to advance the quality and knowledge base for underlying mechanisms in yoga.

The author chooses to include clinical trials and reviews to increase the pool of evidence though some low quality studies did not include adequate randomization may expose results to bias or confounding variables. As the purpose of this review is to summarize the potential underlying mechanisms of yoga therapy for health benefit, no conclusions should be drawn regarding the accuracy of hypotheses or efficacy of treatment for outcome effects.

Recommendations for future research

Previous authors state that immune function is underrepresented in yoga research [8] and these findings agree that immunology is a potential area for future consideration. In addition, oxidative stress, effects of behavioural, social and psychological experiences of yoga need to be better understood from a western medical point of view. The internal and external validity of future studies could be improved to address current worries of bias, limited generalizability and exposure to confounding variables. These methodological considerations should include the implementation of high-quality randomized controlled trials that measure disease-specific health outcomes, the use of well-defined characteristics of intervention and parallel testing of hypothetical underlying effects with components and specific outcome measures.

Conclusion

The effects of yoga on the endocrine system, nervous system, and physical health are documented with high frequency in the literature.

The strongest empirical evidence suggests yoga’s capacity to regulate hormones is a factor in providing health benefit, with a decrease of cortisol and increase of serotonin and melatonin levels following regular practice. Psychological, behavioural, religious or kinaesthetic effects of yoga seem deemphasized in the evidence. Emerging theories that warrant further investigation include biomarkers of immune function, oxidative stress and evidence for facilitating nerve conduction to relieve pain and stress. The extensive and varied components of yoga intervention (asana, pranayama, dhyana, philosophical teaching) indicate yoga is a complex intervention, therefore, to improve the clinical understanding of how yoga might work as a whole, empirical investigation into the components of yoga and testing of their specific outcomes is prospect for future study.

Acknowledgements

The author acknowledges Dr. Carl Heneghan and Dr. Alison Ward for their academic supervision and mentorship.

References

  1. Dangerfield A (2009) Yoga wars.
  2. The yoga sutras of patanjali (2010) In S.S. Satchidananda (Ed), The yoga sutras of patanjali (15 edn). Buckingham, United States of America: Integral Yoga Publications.
  3. Taylor M (2012) What is yoga therapy? An IAYT definition. Yoga therapy in practice.
  4. Macy D (2012) Yoga journal releases 2008 “Yoga in America” market study. Yoga journal.
  5. National Health Services (2012) A guide to yoga.
  6. Büssing A, Michalsen A, Khalsa SBS, Telles S, Sherman KJ (2012) Effects of yoga on mental and physical health: A short summary of reviews. Evidence-based Complementary and Alternative Medicine.
  7. Ernst E, Lee M S (2010) How effective is yoga? A concise overview of systematic reviews. Focus on Alternative and Complementary Therapies15: 274-279.
  8. Field T (2011) Yoga clinical research review. Complement Ther Clin Pract17: 1-8.
  9. Medical Research Council (2009) Developing and evaluating complex interventions: New guidance.
  10. Craig P, Dieppe P, Macintyre S, Michie S, Nazareth I, et al. (2008) Developing and evaluating complex interventions: The new medical research council guidance. International Journal of Nursing Studies.
  11. Oswal P, Nagarathna R, Ebnezar J, Nagendra HR (2011) The effect of add-on yogic pranaenergization technique (YPET) on healing of fresh fractures: A randomized control study. J Altern Complement Med 17: 253-258.
  12. Sengupta P (2012) Health impacts of yoga and pranayama: A state-of-the-art review. Int J Prev Med3: 444-458.
  13. Fong KY, Cheung RT, Yu YL, Lai CW, Chang CM (1993) Basilar artery occlusion following yoga exercise: A case report. Clin ExpNeurol30: 104-109.
  14. Innes KE, Bourguignon C, Taylor AG (2005) Risk indices associated with the insulin resistance syndrome, cardiovascular disease, and possible protection with yoga: A systematic review. J Am Board Fam Pract18: 491-519.
  15. Shea BJ, Hamel C, Wells GA, Bouter LM, Kristjansson E, et al. (2009) AMSTAR is a reliable and valid measurement tool to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviews. J Clin Epidemiol62: 1013-1020.
  16. Turner L, Shamseer L, Altman DG, Weeks L, Peters J, et al. (2012) Consolidated standards of reporting trials (CONSORT) and the completeness of reporting of randomised controlled trials (rcts) published in medical journals. Cochrane Database Syst Rev11:MR000030.
  17. Hegde SV, Adhikari P, Kotian S, Pinto VJ, D’Souza S, et al. (2011) Effect of 3-month yoga on oxidative stress in type 2 diabetes with or without complications: A controlled clinical trial. Diabetes Care34: 2208-2210.
  18. Kiecolt-Glaser JK, Christian L, Preston H, Houts CR, Malarkey WB, et al. (2010) Stress, inflammation, and yoga practice. Psychosom Med 72:113-121.
  19. Vera FM, Manzaneque JM, Maldonado EF, Carranque GA, Rodriguez FM, et al. (2009) Subjective sleep quality and hormonal modulation in long-term yoga practitioners. BiolPsychol81: 164-168.
  20. Brotto LA, Mehak L, Kit C (2009) Yoga and sexual functioning: A review. J Sex Marital Ther35: 378-390.
  21. Balaji PA, Varne SR, Ali SS (2012) Physiological effects of yogic practices and transcendental meditation in health and disease. N Am J Med Sci4: 442-448.
  22. Kinser PA, Goehler LE, Taylor AG (2012) How might yoga help depression? A neurobiological perspective. Explore (NY)8: 118-126.
  23. Streeter CC, Gerbarg PL, Saper RB, Ciraulo DA, Brown RP (2012) Effects of yoga on the autonomic nervous system, gamma-aminobutyric-acid, and allostasis in epilepsy, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder. Med Hypotheses 78: 571-579.
  24. Wren AA, Wright MA, Carson JW, Keefe FJ (2011) Yoga for persistent pain: New findings and directions for an ancient practice. Pain 152: 477-480.
  25. Balk J, Bernardo LM (2011) Using yoga to promote bone health and reduce fracture risk in the geriatric population. Topics in Geriatric Rehabilitation 27: 116-123.
  26. Sahay BK (2007) Role of yoga in diabetes. J Assoc Physicians India 55: 121- 126.
  27. Sharma M, Knowlden AP (2012) Role of yoga in preventing and controlling type 2 diabetes mellitus. Journal of Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine17: 88-95.
  28. McIver S, McGartland M, O’Halloran P (2009) Overeating is not about the food: Women describe their experience of a yoga treatment program for binge eating. Qualitative Health Research19: 1234-1245.
  29. Sies H (1991) Oxidative stress: From basic research to clinical application. Am J Med91: 31-38.
  30. Dunn KD (2008) A review of the literature examining the physiological processes underlying the therapeutic benefits of hatha yoga. Adv Mind Body Med23: 10-18.
  31. Pavlov VA, Tracey KJ (2012) Thevagus nerve and the inflammatory reflex– linking immunity and metabolism. Nat Rev Endocrinol 8: 743-754.
  32. Kulkarni DD, Bera TK (2009) Yogic exercises and health – A psycho-neuro immunological approach. Indian J Physiol Pharmacol 53: 3-15.
  33. Hernandez-Reif M, Field T, Ironson G, Beutler J, Vera Y, et al. (2005) Natural killer cells and lymphocytes increase in women with breast cancer following massage therapy. Int J Neurosci115: 495-510.
  34. Tenforde TS (1992) Biological interactions and potential health effects of extremely-low-frequency magnetic fields from power lines and other common sources. Annu Rev Public Health 13: 173-196.
  35. Kuntsevich V, Bushell WC, Theise ND (2010) Mechanisms of yogic practices in health, aging, and disease. Mt Sinai J Med 77: 559-569.